School debt is predatory too, and the alternatives nobody pushes hard enough
Same structure as a payday loan: a product sold as the only door, to people with the least leverage to negotiate it.
I wrote recently about predatory payday loans, small-dollar credit marketed to people in a moment of need, structured so the renewal, not the payoff, is the profitable outcome. I want to make an uncomfortable comparison: a meaningful slice of student lending operates on the same structural logic, just stretched over decades instead of weeks, and dressed up in a story about opportunity instead of a fluorescent storefront.
I’m not saying every student loan is predatory, or that college is a scam. I have a degree; it’s served me fine. I’m saying the category deserves the same scrutiny we’d apply to any other large, hard-to-escape debt sold to people, 17 and 18 year olds, who are, almost by definition, the least equipped age group in the country to evaluate a six-figure financial commitment.
What makes it structurally similar to predatory lending
The borrower can’t realistically price the product. An 18-year-old comparing a $60,000 private loan to a $15,000 community-college-then-transfer path doesn’t have the financial literacy, and often doesn’t have a parent with the financial literacy, to actually run that comparison the way an adult would price a mortgage. The industry knows this. Financial aid offices present “your award letter” with numbers that frequently bury the actual total cost and the actual interest accrual behind language designed to read better than it is.
The debt is nearly impossible to discharge. Outside of narrow hardship provisions, student debt survives bankruptcy in a way almost no other consumer debt does. Compare that to a payday loan, which at least disappears in a Chapter 7 filing. Student debt is structurally closer to a tax obligation than to ordinary credit, it follows you regardless of outcome, whether you finished the degree, whether the degree led to a job in the field, whether the school itself folded.
Private loans in particular often carry variable rates with thin disclosure, marketed hardest to students and families who didn’t max out cheaper federal options first, sometimes because nobody explained the federal options exist and should be exhausted first, every time, before a single private dollar is borrowed.
The renewal-style economics show up as compounding, not rollover. A payday loan compounds via a new fee every two weeks. An unsubsidized or private student loan compounds interest the entire time you’re in school, before you’ve earned a dollar against it, meaning a freshman-year loan balance is measurably larger by graduation than the amount actually disbursed, for reasons that were never made vivid to the 18-year-old who signed for it.
None of this means don’t ever borrow for school. It means treat it with the same suspicion you’d apply to any other large loan sold to you in a moment when you have the least leverage and the least information, because structurally, that’s what it is.
The alternatives that get undersold
Start at community college, transfer to finish the four-year degree. This is the single highest-leverage move available to most students and it gets pitched as a consolation prize instead of a strategy. The diploma you receive at graduation says the four-year school’s name, not “transferred from community college”, and the cost difference is enormous: average community college tuition runs a fraction of a four-year public school’s, and a fraction of a percent of most private schools’. Two years at community college followed by two years at the four-year school you transfer into can cut total tuition cost by 40-60% for an identical final degree.
The catch, and it’s a real one: transfer credits don’t always map cleanly. Before enrolling anywhere, check the specific transfer agreement between your target community college and your target four-year school, most states now have formal articulation agreements that guarantee credit transfer for specific course sequences. Don’t assume; verify with both schools’ registrar offices before you take a single class, because a poorly planned transfer can cost you extra semesters that eat into the savings.
Free community college programs. A growing number of states now offer some form of free community college, sometimes called a “promise” program, covering tuition for residents who meet basic enrollment and GPA requirements. Availability and rules vary significantly by state and change year to year, so check your specific state’s higher education agency website directly rather than relying on outdated articles; this is a fast-moving area of state policy.
In-state public school over private, almost every time, for an undergraduate degree. The earnings premium of a private undergraduate degree over a quality in-state public school is, for the overwhelming majority of fields and employers, smaller than the tuition gap. This isn’t true at the very top tier of name-brand schools with elite recruiting pipelines into specific industries, but for most students in most fields, it’s true, and it’s worth being clear-eyed about before signing for the difference.
Exhaust federal aid and scholarships before a single private loan dollar. Federal student loans carry fixed rates, income-driven repayment options, and forgiveness pathways that private loans simply don’t offer. The order matters: grants and scholarships first (free money, see the companion post on this site about treating scholarship hunting like a paid job), then federal loans, and private loans only as a true last resort, for the smallest amount possible, after everything else is exhausted.
Look hard at the trades and apprenticeships as a genuine alternative, not a fallback, covered in detail in the companion post on this site. For a meaningful number of careers, an apprenticeship gets you to a comparable or better income with zero debt, years earlier.
The question to actually ask before borrowing
Not “can I get approved for this loan”, almost everyone can, which is itself a signal, the same way payday lenders approve almost everyone. The real question: what is the total amount I’ll owe at graduation, what is the realistic starting salary in my actual intended field at this actual school, and does the math work without assuming the best-case outcome?
If the answer requires assuming you land a top-quartile job in your field immediately upon graduation to make the payments comfortable, that’s not a financial plan, that’s a bet. It’s worth knowing that’s what you’re making before you sign. A cursory Google search doesn’t always show realistic entry-level earnings so make sure you get usable information.
This is informational, not individualized financial advice, and student aid rules vary by state and change frequently, verify current details with your state’s higher education agency and the specific schools you’re considering before deciding. If debt is already part of your picture, the balance transfer math post on this site covers one legitimate tool for high-interest debt generally.
Get the free $0-to-First-Property Roadmap
The five-stage plan I used to go from living in a van to owning a duplex — no rich parents required. Enter your email and I’ll send it straight to your inbox.
The First-Property Bundle
The step-by-step playbook, the six-calculator deal-analyzer toolkit, and the down-payment-assistance finder — the exact system I used to go from a van to a duplex.
Pay what you want. Name your price — and if money’s tight, take it for less.
Get the bundle →Get the free $0-to-First-Property Roadmap
The five-stage plan I used to go from living in a van to owning a duplex, no rich parents required.